Wednesday, March 28, 2012

The Restless Dead

Last night, after the debate, I headed back to my car, satisfied after a long day at work.  A ten minute drive home and I would be safe in the bosom of my family, with dinner on the table. But it was not to be, for a dark fate awaited me that night.
 As I went down the Rankin steps, I felt a prick at the edge of my awareness, like someone--or something--was watching me.  I stopped, looked around, but no one was there.  I shrugged and went on.
The pricking grew stronger, though, and a flicker of movement in the shadows caught my eye.  A patch of inky blackness stirred, darker even than the surrounding shadow.  I shivered.  Strange things have been known to lurk around Rankin Hall, things that I wanted no part of.
"George..."  A faint whisper carried across the still night air.
Goosebumps prickled my skin.  What business did it have with me? 
"George..."  The voice grew more demanding.  It sounded hollow, like the echo from an empty tomb, like nothing that a living man should have to hear.
I walked faster, trying to put more distance myself and the shade.
"George!"
Shaking, I surrendered to my fate and faced the monster.   
The darkness grew closer, until I could make out lines within it, vertical stripes of white filling the shape of a man.
No, I thought, it couldn't be!
I tried to run, but my feet were frozen with fear.  My mouth opened, but no sound came out.
Still closer the spirit came, confirming my worst fears--it was the shade of Russell Kirk in his thick-striped suit, roused from his earthen bed in Michigan to haunt me this night.
"George."  He called again, impatient.   "Why do you reject me?"
"W...wh...what?"  I stuttered, my voice only a weak reed in the face of his ghastly countenance.
 "Why do you reject my teachings on diversity?"  The graveyard echoes rolled over me.    "Why do you let students speak falsely, saying that bringing in the author of Heather has Two Mommies brings diversity because it represents a non-mainstream view?"
"What do you mean?"  I ventured hesitantly.  "It's a reasonable argument, my colleagues use it all the time.  Diversity should mean bringing in non-mainstream views, and--"
"Sure it's a reasonable argument...at Bob Jones University!"  His mocking laughter sent shivers up my spine.
"But--"
"Idiot!"  In a flash his laughter turned to fury.  Even in life he hadn't suffered fools gladly, and death hadn't improved his temper.  "Did you read anything I wrote?"
"I--" But he wouldn't let me defend myself.  Floating closer, he pressed closer, and a gust of fetid breath struck me as he continued.
"Concrete reality, damn you!  Let the Progressives talk about abstract statistical averages that don't exist anywhere outside their own imagination; conservatives must never forget the concrete reality!" 
"Well, I--"
 "You've seen the "aga1nst" buttons, you've seen the "gay, fine by me" t-shirts, you've seen the anti-amendment rally on campus--how many have you seen supporting the amendment?"
"But that doesn't mean people don't support the amendment.  Maybe they're just staying quiet because people might take it as anti-gay harassment and charge them under the speech code--"
"So if the school only tolerates one side's speech, the "diverse" thing to do is pay some one to support that side?"  He sneered.
 "Wait." I temporized.  "We can test this.  Empirically."
He looked skeptical, but didn't interrupt.
"The election on May 8.  We can look at the election results from Appalachian's voting precinct.  If Amendment 1 passes in this precinct, then we can say they're right, the "diversity series" actually does bring diversity to campus.   And if the amendment loses, then we know that by bringing in speakers like the Heather has Two Mommies author, the "diversity series" just preaching to the choir, chanting the same mantra as everyone else."
"And?"  He asked.
"If they really believe what they said in class."  I went on.  "They should believe Amendment 1 will win at Appalachian."
"So let them take responsibility for their beliefs.  Let them bet their grade on it.  As many points as they want--to gain if the vote goes one way, and lose if it goes the other."
"So if Amendment 1 loses in this precinct, they lose whatever points they bet?"  I looked skeptical.
"If your students really believe that bringing those speakers to campus brings diversity, they must be confident they'll win.  Why not give them a chance to prove they're right?"  He lowered his voice to a seductive whisper.  "They can upstage the professor and get a better grade.  What could possibly be wrong with that?"
"But that might mean taking points away from students.  That wouldn't be...nice"  I protested weakly, fighting the foul spirit's temptation.
"Nice?!"  The tempter's mask fell away, revealing the cauldron of seething cantankerousness within.
"Is that what you think teaching is?!  Shielding them from the consequences of their beliefs, like they were little children?   Shouldn't you be teaching a class on Progressivism instead?" He jeered.
"Alright!"  I growled, stung by his mockery.   "I'll do it.  I'll let students bet however many points they want on the outcome of the Amendment 1 vote in the Appalachian State precinct.  Heck, I'll do you one better, you old bastard, I'll give them 3:2 odds that the amendment will fail in this precinct."
Russell Kirk leaned back, crossing his arms across his ghostly chest.  As he faded from view, the crossed stripes of his chest and sleeves lingered like a net, one in which he had neatly entrapped me.
"And as you go about your days and works, remember.  I am the voice of tradition, and you will never, ever, be free of me."  
I gulped, imagining that hideous presence watching and judging me.   What had I done to deserve this curse?  I asked myself. 
With a last shudder, I hurried to my car and turned on all the lights.  For a long time I sat there, breathing deeply and waiting for my heart to slow.   Only when I was sure his undead presence had vanished completely did I set out for the warmth of hearth and home.

[OOC: if you really believe the argument about diversity, you can make it real in the comments section.   Announce how many points--out of the ones you've earned so far--you want to bet.  If Amendment 1 wins a majority in the ASU precinct, you keep those points and I'll add 150% of the number to your total.  If Amendment 1 gets less than a majority in the ASU precinct, you lose all the points you bet.]

7 comments:

  1. While I am not comfortable taking that bet, I will say that you shouldnt disparage youre writing chops so readily..

    As a counter - I think that Justin was referring to larger society in saying that anti-gay (or at the least uncomfortable-with-gay) opinions are the norm. Taking the microcosm of a university campus may easily yield different results. On the other hand it may not, I really don't know what to expect in the outcome of the vote, and thats why I'd rather not bet on it.

    Finally, with reference to the efficacy of the "diversity" programs - they probably are largely preaching to the choir. What person who does not agree with homosexual couples raising children would attend "___ has two mommies"? If they did would their opinion be swayed by the presentation? Probably not. The only way for opinions already so set in the heads of their holders to change would be to have some sort of intimate personal experience that a presentation in a diversity lecture series would be hard pressed to deliver.

    Daniel DeCarlo

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. "I think that Justin was referring to larger society... "

      That's exactly the point! Where is the speech happening? In the "larger society?" No.

      Like I said, if the speech was happening at Bob Jones University it would absolutely contribute to diversity. Kirk's demand is that we realize we don't live in an abstract "larger society," we live in a specific place--ASU, Boone, NC--and make decisions on that basis.

      Delete
  2. I believe this account would more accurately describe the entire U.S. population than here at ASU. State Universities are hot beds for liberalism. Not much different than when our parents were this age. My Dad went to UNC-Chapel Hill and participated in plenty of the liberal "equality" and "one world" events while there. Then he got a job, entered the real world, and now refers to himself as a "Hardcore-Reagan-Republican;" as he believes in college he was too young and ignorant to understand how the world works.

    My point is, the general U.S. populous is likely pro-amendment I (at least in the opinion) though not by much. However here at ASU, it will undoubtedly be shot down. College kids tend to like a no-rules do whatever you want society. While I myself could care less about gay marriage either way, many of my peers seem to be extremely pro-gay marriage.

    I just wanted to put my 2 cents in. I believe without a doubt that amendment I will not pass here at App, but I'll take the 25 points for the post. Gambling, betting, and lottery-style "hope" for points do not produce a hard worker in my opinion. I would not be doing myself justice if I relied on a welfare-esque liberal systems to make grades in college. I'll earn my points....the Conservative way.

    David C. Tate

    ReplyDelete
  3. I enjoyed your writing. It had a "Tell Tail Heart" tone. To the question at hand, I believe that amendment 1 will fail at ASU. It must be stated that ASU has two polling places and I believe that means there are two precincts that comprise campus.
    I take the typical stand that the youth vote is more liberal and democratic than it it conservative. The youth have supported the liberal causes since the activist days of the 1960's. It is safe to assume if every ASU student was asked how they felt about amendment 1 the vast majority would reject it. The issue of gay marriage does not appeal to many young republicans. Most conservative youth support legalized same sex marriage. It is a issue that divides the youth from older republicans. However this is not the issue at hand, the issue is how many students will show up at the polls. Simply put, the youth don't vote. Even though this is a presidential election year, amendment 1 is on the GOP primary date. This will decrease the overall student turn out. But as I have stated before same sex marriage is supported by the youth on both sides. There is a much larger campaign on ASU's campus to defeat the measure than to support it. I am not confident but I believe Amendment 1 will be defeated on our campus. I am willing to bet 100 points. (does the 150% work both ways?)
    I understand lower voter turn out but there are 17,000 students at ASU and the rest of Boone is roughly 10,000 people. If all students voted and united on student issues, IE the noise ordiance or campus expansion and we voted as a block then it would not matter what the town wanted. The students would win every single time. There is power in voting.
    Daniel, I understand your contention about a person that disagrees not going to "Heather has two mommies" but I and a few are liberal but are taking a conservatism class.
    Dr. Ehrhardtm, it would be fantastic if your or another professor in the department taught a progressiveism class.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Because I'm an optimist, I think that within the bubble of progressivism (albeit within Dan Soucek and Virginia Foxx's respective districts) that is Appalachian's campus, there's a decent chance that Amendment I will not pass.

    The movement to support marriage equality may seem like the "norm" to the culture warriors in our class, but I disagree. The fact that a redundant and discriminatory amendment to our state constitution is even on this May ballot, I think, indicates that the public sentiment on or off Appalachian's campus is not supportive of this cause.

    Relying on Ian's logic of voter turnout, I think that generally moderate and conservative Appalachian students will follow the trend of our generation's voting style - i.e. not voting. That means those with a strong conviction or vested interest in the Amendment's defeat will be represented more heavily at the polls.

    Despite all this, I'm optimistic that our generation is on the cusp of a shift in thinking about equal protection and citizenship. I'll bet 25 points.

    As the Conservative-in-Chief himself, Ronald Reagan, said in his first inaugural address, "How can we love our country and not love our countrymen."

    - Justin Herberger

    ReplyDelete
  5. One must first consider who is most likely to vote in May. It is not Obama in need of this primary season.

    Here's the scoop on the amendment as stated on ballotpedia.org

    "The North Carolina Same-Sex Marriage Amendment will appear on the May 8, 2012 ballot in the state of North Carolina as a legislatively-referred constitutional amendment.

    The measure would define marriage in the state as between one man and one woman.[1][2]

    Same-sex marriage is already banned in the state of North Carolina. The proposed measure, however, would add the ban to the state constitution.[3]

    Debated in the state legislature during the Spring 2011 legislative session, the amendment failed to receive sufficient votes to qualify for the ballot. However, the measure was debated during the Fall session which began September 12, 2011.[4] That very day, the House voted 75-42 in favor of referring the proposed amendment to the statewide ballot.[5] The State Senate echoed the House with a 30-16 approval vote a day later on September 13, 2011.[6]"

    The amendment is moot. NC has already banned same sex marriage. This just puts it on the state constitution.

    Be smart, do your research, and trust no one. Remember to think for yourself.

    As for betting, I have seen to many things happen on the political landscape since the 2000 presidential election, and especially this primary season to stake any hard earned points on this outcome.

    I will get my A the old fashioned way, the conservative way, I will EARN it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well put Charles!

      Dr. Ehrhardt handing out points earlier in the semester, and this gambling opportunity is a challenge to conservative beliefs!

      have a great break all!

      Delete